Culpa Nuestra (Our Fault) Review: A Passionate Closure To Nick And Noah’s Tumultuous Love Story

My Fault (2023) and Your Fault (2024), this Spanish language romantic drama is based on the best selling novels by Mercedes Ron, and continues the character's complicated journey through a complicated romance filled with tragedy, romance and redemptions.

Oct 16, 2025 - 11:38
 0
Culpa Nuestra (Our Fault) Review: A Passionate Closure To Nick And Noah’s Tumultuous Love Story
Image Source: Our Fault Trailer

Culpa Nuestra (translated to Our Fault) has finally released on October 16, 2025, and provides a bittersweet finale to the Culpables trilogy, exclusively on Amazon Prime Video. Side-stepping most sequels, the film reunites director Domingo González and co-writer Sofía Cuenca, along with stars Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara as the passionate but fragile lovers, Noah and Nick. Like the previous two films, My Fault (2023) and Your Fault (2024), this Spanish language romantic drama is based on the best selling novels by Mercedes Ron, and continues the character's complicated journey through a complicated romance filled with tragedy, romance and redemptions.

Storyline

The plot takes place several years after the conclusion of Your Fault. Noah and Nick are separated and are forced into each other on the wedding day of their best friends, Lion and Jenna. Noah has come to terms with being a more mature and dependent woman; whereas, Nick is a young billionaire working through resentment and regret.

Although both try to maintain their distance, their chemistry quickly rebounds, leading the both of them with a whirlwind of emotions. As the plot unfolds, old secrets are revealed about the breakup which ultimately leads to painful confrontations. At one point a shocking twist occurs.

Positive Points

Performances by Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara are relatable, and they share a strong emotion that is the series' emotional core. Domingo González's direction brings the passion and the tension, and paired with the cinematography and music, the love story is intensified. 

Also Read: Wonder Man Trailer Review: Yahya Abdul-Mateen II Brings Meta Madness To The MCU

Negative Points

At certain points, the melodrama is overdone with too many twists crammed into the third act. Some of the pacing is off, and several of the supporting character appearances could have been explored more. 

Overall: Culpa Nuestra is an intense and emotionally satisfying conclusion. It may not be perfect, but it captures the turmoil that is Nick and Noah's romance beautifully, making it an adequate ending on behalf of the Culpables saga.